Dismissal – Reasonable Settlement Offer

The school district’s lawyer can ask the tribunal to file a dismissal application. They can do so for various reasons.

One of the reasons is if they have offered you a reasonable settlement offer and you refused to accept it. And that standard of “reasoanble” is going to be determined by the tribunal based on similar cases to yours and what they would award at a hearing.

This case isn’t education-related, but it explains this area quite well. The school districts can’t make this type of application if you are all within 4 months of the hearing. They would have to do this before the 4-month cut-off period. So if you want a hearing and you can get past this time frame, you’ll be good to go for your hearing.

If you think your complaint is novel (new) for the tribunal or that your case can advance the Human Rights Code, you could argue back and see if you make it through. There is no risk. Even if you don’t win your application, you will have some time to accept their reasonable offer.

Here is the info sheet from the BC HRT on this topic.

********

Dhillon v. Interfor Corporation, 2026 BCHRT 246

[56]         In Dar Santos, the Tribunal set out what was meant by the “purposes of the Code” in s. 27(1)(d)(ii):

… I accept that, the “purposes of the Code” go beyond the individual rights of a complainant and respondent.  The purposes of the Code, as outlined in s. 3, include several public policy purposes.  Thus, the assessment of whether proceeding with a complaint will further the purposes of the Code, involves more than an assessment of an individual complaint, but encompasses broader public policy issues, such as the efficiency and responsiveness of the human rights system, and the expense and time involved in processing a complaint to a hearing.  (para. 59)

[57]         Interfor says proceeding with a hearing will not serve the public interest, and there is no reason for the parties to endure the stress and uncertainty of a hearing in these circumstances. It says the allegations are not unique or novel, as other cases have considered issue of whether mandatory work safety policies infringe upon religious rights, particularly for people following the Sikh faith. In support, it cites Singh Toor v. Finlay Forest Industries Ltd., 1984 CanLII 5062 (BC HRT); Bhinder v. CN, [1985] 2 SCR 561; Pannu v. Skeena Cellulose, 2000 BCHRT 56.

[58]         In general, it does not further the purposes of the Code to proceed to a hearing where the respondent has made a reasonable settlement offer: Akinbiyi v. Community Builders Benevolence Group (No.2), 2025 BCHRT 177 at para. 46, citing Salanguit v. Parq Vancouver and another, 2024 BCHRT 119 at para. 47.

[59]         In this case, there are no factors that weigh in favour of proceeding to a hearing considering Interfor’s reasonable settlement offer. I am not persuaded that the issues are novel or engage broader public policy issues such that it outweighs the strong public interest in parties resolving their disputes, and in not using scarce Tribunal resources after a reasonable settlement offer has been rejected. Allowing this complaint to proceed to a hearing would require considerable resources and would not further the purpose of a just and timely human rights system.

[60]         In conclusion, I am persuaded that Interfor made a reasonable settlement offer, and there are no factors that weigh in favour of this complaint proceeding to a hearing.

[61]         Interfor’s settlement offer is reasonable, and it would not further the purposes of the Code to allow the complaint to proceed. I therefore grant the application and dismiss the complaint under s. 27(1)(d)(ii) of the Code.

[62]         In considering this application to dismiss, I have assumed Mr. Dhillon would prove his complaint at a hearing. However, there is no guarantee that he would succeed at a hearing. The Tribunal could accept Interfor’s defence and dismiss the complaint, leaving him with no remedy. Interfor’s settlement offer gives him a certain result and avoids the time, expense, and stress of a legal process with an uncertain outcome. As set out in Interfor’s materials, Mr. Dhillon has two weeks following the date of this decision to accept the offer.

Here is the dismissal application form they will need to fill out. In this form, they have the info sheets linked for all of the different reasons they can apply to dismiss.