Parents in BC are restricted to information that other parents have access to in other provinces in Canada.
Two examples:
- Legal fees for human rights complaints
- Teachers’ Regulation Branch (TRB) – Ministry of Education
.
Legal Fees
Parents of Carter Churchill won a human rights complaint against the Newfoundland and Labrador English School District (full Case here). They submitted an Freedom of Information request (FOI) and they got the complete breakdown of legal fees. It revealed what they spent their legal costs on to fight a 5-year old Deaf child from access an interpreter in kindergarten – $682 thousand dollars. Here is an article on it.
When I sent the exact same FOI request to my child’s district, I got S.14 – client privilege arguments. I filed an OIPC complaint and the OIPC backed them up. The districts arguments were that the breakdown would reveal legal communications. When I asked OIPC why I couldn’t access the same information that other parents could in another province I was told that the BC privacy laws are different in BC.
If you want to know the legal fees I recommend you go the route of filing an FOI with the Ministry of Finance. Ask for the total costs, not the break down. When you file the FOI tell them you are filing it under S.25 – public interest. If they fight you, you can offer up this case. Order 1728
Ok, now let’s talk about the TRB
Teacher’s Documents – TRB
In Ontario when parents file a complaint against a teacher, the teacher will respond to the complaint. The parents/caregivers get a copy of that. In BC, we do not. You will have no idea what the teacher submitted in their own defense or what they said. In my experience, it’s usually a pack of lies. If you file a FOI request you will get one piece of paper with a section written on it.
There is a new OIPC decision that outlines the legal arguments that BC has that keeps everything a teacher submits away from parental eyes. Order F26-10. The OIPC clearly does not want the Ministry of Education and Child Care filing a Judicial Review. While the parent is going to receive process documents, still nothing. Backed up by BC laws and an adjudicator who doesn’t think the public cares enough about education or the TRB. If anyone or organization wants to fight this, this decision is your stepping stone. It outlines all of the legal issues you are going to need to navigate. This is a stepping stone for anyone who wants to take this issue and elevate their fight.
In the meantime, we can use our knowledge of the system to get access to all of these documents in other ways. That way is the HUMAN RIGHTS TRIBUNAL. If a mediation meeting fails and you are continuing along in your complaint, you will reach a document disclosure stage. You can file a general application for documents. The school districts lawyers are going to try and persuade you of this. They will tell you that your request is “inappropriate” and send you to the TRB. (By the way – when they tell you what you are doing is inappropriate – you have hit a nerve. You are probably on the right track and they are very nervous about you continuing.) Do not believe them when they tell you to go to the TRB. They know it is a dead end. The evidence that I received getting documents from the TRB was fall of your chair, shocking evidence. Things I wasn’t even expecting or would have thought to ask for. I filed on a group of people and they ended up trying to blame the other person, submitting evidence that the other person was guilty. Beautiful! Thank you very much for that. So, they feel very safe that their documents are going to be protected. Use their false sense of safety. If the lawyers are offering you a settlement agreement you can’t live with, you can let them know that you will be filing an application for TRB documents. You can use the arguments of relevance and credibility of a future witness.
Remember that school districts will never just lay out all of the evidence you need due to their goals of reducing their liability. Also, if you want to ponder over who has all the decision making power in this process, here is blog about this question, the riddle of who is Wizard of Oz pulling all the strings.
Conclusion
BC’s privacy laws are stricter in BC, or the organizations in BC just don’t have a backbone to go up against the government. Either way… not so great for us. But we can use another routes through the maze to get what we want. The more you know about how to navigate all of the external complaint systems, the further you will get.
